Suggestion for Gems, Bps(making chests and cauldrons better as a result)

Share your ideas on how to improve Shop Heroes.
Forum rules
Please check other threads before posting a suggestion or providing feedback to make sure that there are no duplicate threads on the same subject. We value your feedback and suggestions and will prioritize those with the most demand, however, please be patient with us as we already have a very packed pipeline for new content delivery. Any feedback that has already been taken into account will result in the thread being locked as further discussions are no longer necessary.
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Jun 13, 2015 6:27 am

Suggestion for Gems, Bps(making chests and cauldrons better as a result)

Postby neuralburn » Fri Nov 24, 2017 12:31 pm

I was ranting about this in world chat and thought it would be a pretty good combination of things. Pardon me if this has all already been suggested before.

As I see it, the main use for gems is to buy the gear you want in Trade house. Not many people would realistically spend gems boosting an exceptional craft or cauldron outside of possibly to speed up crafting endgame gear. Further, drop rate of chests makes it very difficult for new people to catch up. At best you're looking at a small group of people buying gems to 1 - open chests and 2 - buy end game gear. There is some need to buy premium slots but that dies out fairly quickly. From there, what motivation do folks have to keep buying gems?

I want to suggest the following:
1. Sell and reward more Blueprint Fragments as a middle-level "premium currency"
* This has three benefits. BPF is untradeable and thus the value of BPF is static and easy to control by CC. It also takes out the RNG aspect of using gems and keys for chests. It reduces influx of gems that aren't from revenue.
- Boost the use of blueprint fragments as rewards - remove some artifact rewards from raids and use 2-3 BPF instead.
- Remove artifact rewards from chests and instead provide blueprints as the lowest reward, instead.
- Allow blueprint fragments to be used towards mastering crafts
- Sell blueprint fragments for $$ in the shop.
- Increase BPF cost from magic chest items going forward, to compensate for increased BPFs coming in
- Depending on your plans for gem lady in this patch, keep her!

2. Decrease the gem costs to encourage Gem use and purchase of gems from shop.
* Purpose: More usage of gems means that fewer will sit idle on a small number of players as it trickles upward. Also, due to the tradehouse limits and as more and more gold enters the game, gems already increase in value from a trade perspective. Hoewver, this has the negative impact of fewer and fewer gems being used in Trade, overall as buying precrafts becomes less and less attractive. This means gems are not being taxed enough or leaving the game as fast as they could. To counter this - make other usage of gems more attractive.
- Decrease cost of gems to speed up Cauldron, limiting to 50 gems/day and 250 gems overall
- right now i'm seeing 250+ gems for a 2 day craft. Imagine those 16 day crafts @ level 55...i'm sure people would be happy to spend 250 gems time and time again to crank those out.
- Decrease cost of gems to boost exceptional crafts up to Flawless -> epic by 90%
- Decreasing cost of gems to repair up to and including Legendary items by a large number as well. Perhaps not 90% to continue to encourage use of crafting Support / Resourceful items.
- In the same vein, decreasing cost of gems to heal and revive
- Decreasing the cost of gems to boost buildings to 1 per boost, but make those gem donations not count towards player networth.
- I have no idea what the exchange rate is, but 5.63k gems vs 200mil to boost level 50 castle 4x means nobody will ever use gems to boost castle. If this was 4 gems, i'd be burning gems all day.
- Drop gem cost to speed up crafts by about 75%. It is almost reasonable now at 50/hr but not quite usable on a massive scale.

3. With regards to #2 above, I'd like to suggest having an event that implements those changes as a trial
4. Optionally, make some of the above changes require user having a premium slot for the craft, cauldron, quest, etc. This encourages purchase of premium slots for gems.

User avatar
"Legendary" Mastery Member
Posts: 2733
Joined: Sun Aug 23, 2015 11:05 am
Location: the Netherlands

Re: Suggestion for Gems, Bps(making chests and cauldrons better as a result)

Postby Shiroe » Fri Nov 24, 2017 3:02 pm

Artifacts-wise, you'd probably want to keep Araginite and Hellfire Ruby in the Primal chests, but the other artifacts are underwhelming in most cases. (although artifacts in the wooden/leather chests probably have more tradehouse value than most items in those. ;) )

My impression was that things like repairing kind of were intentionally priced in "we don't want you to use this unless you're a very big whale" territory...
At one time a few of the shop upgrades were more economical to do with gems than with gold, but the inflation kind of undid that.

I'm guessing most players are in these broad categories w.r.t gems:
- spending them on slot unlocks such as cauldron and getting gold through the tradehouse
- mostly spending them on chests (and mostly getting them from the tradehouse, see the last bit of the previous entry)
- after having all chest blueprints, spend them on things such as buying leg/myth gear on the tradehouse, some epic->legendary upgrades or some fusion speedups. (if the expected cost would be more economical vs buying the item on trade)

As long as the flow of gems they can get through the tradehouse is still high enough, I don't think people in the 2nd and 3rd category would often pick buying gems over a buying package.
* continues with the annoyingly-3-steps "make gold, flip to gems, slowly turn into blueprint progress through chest openings" process*
as of 2016-09-11: Player level: 44, City: Eolythes, Blueprints: 517, Mastered: 419, Crafted: 78.61K
(except for tier 1 and some tier 2 artifacts mostly running my shop/gearing self sufficient)

Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Jun 13, 2015 6:27 am

Re: Suggestion for Gems, Bps(making chests and cauldrons better as a result)

Postby neuralburn » Sun Nov 26, 2017 5:23 am

Certainly. People making gems in trade house will likely not buy gems. Trade also has the benefit of taking a lot of gems out of the market that otherwise would be stagnant. However, as the gold to gem ratio gets wider and wider, you see things drop in gem value and fewer gems will be burned by tradehouse -- thus fewer gems will be bought by the types of players that buy gems rather than grind out crafts.

I'm sure a large amt of gems are being bought for endgame myths and, with the large gold:gem ratio - people are currently buying gems for their gold value. I believe players would value speedier questing/crafting over gold and it would boost gem usage: benefitting both CC and us bored end gamers sitting for days on fuses.

For example - I'm sitting on several thousand gems. I'm probably going to be crafting my myth end-game gear and not buying it. My primary use for gems will be to occassionally buy legendary fuse-fodder in that time. If, instead, i were compelled to use my gems constantly, i would probably have no stockpile and would probably further consider buying the gem fountain or more rather than use up my time grinding precrafts for gems. As I see it, if i could make 5 pieces of end game myths for 10k gems in a short couple weeks vs several months vs buying them at 15k+ each, it is worth it.

Return to “Suggestions & Feedback”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

©2015 Cloudcade, Inc. All Rights Reserved.